6357 – A course in review

I have chosen to write and reflect on my recent course EDMA 6357. I can confidently say that this was my favorite course taken during my entire MAT program, likely due to the fact that this course focused solely on math teaching and ways to become a better math teacher. What I especially liked about this course was the hands-on, practical element. Each class period was spent practicing, or discussing specific strategies that we could employ to improve our teaching. For instance, we spent an entire class talking and practicing five key discussion talk moves. My class mates and I then had the opportunity to stand in front of the class and practice employing the talk moves as we taught a brief lesson. I appreciated this immediate opportunity to practice and receive feedback because it helped to solidify my understanding and ability to use them.

In another class period we “played” with blocks to “model” what fractions look like. This was by far my favorite class period because it stretched my mind and helped me realize the frustration and confusion that students often feel. The activity also helped me to realize how valuable it is to allow students to play with manipulatives and model different mathematical situations. Lessons can sometimes be so rushed and it is such a great feeling to slow down and really dig into a concept. This activity got me jazzed up about going out and buying all types of fun math games and manipulatives to use in my classroom.

Another component of this course that I truly enjoyed was the close interaction with my peers and the opportunity to just sit and chat with them about math teaching. I wish to carry this type of peer engagement and discussion forward into my career. One of my professional development goals is to join a math teaching community network, whether it be online or in-person. I want to continue to meet with fellow math teachers and discuss various teaching strategies and lesson ideas. From this class I came away with a true appreciation of the benefits that are derived from meeting and discussing with other math teachers. I look forward to growing and exploring as I progress in my career.

6357 – Final Papers

To wrap up my EDMA 6357 course I was asked to prepare a book report on one text that speaks to reform mathematics and to prepare my own math teaching philosophy. For my book report I chose to read “Winning the Math Wars No Teacher Left Behind.” This was a great book and I highly recommend it for those of you interested in understanding the growth and current state of the math wars. It is well-written and a non-biased assessment. I have attached my final report below. I was also asked to prepare my own teaching philosophy. This too can be found below. Enjoy!

Book Report

Math Philosophy

 

6357 – Wait Time

My instructor in EDMA 6357 recently challenged my classmates and I to practicing using more “wait time” after asking a question to students. Wait time is the time in-between asking the question and soliciting a response. I have been practicing using wait-time in my teaching and I do notice a significant difference in the number of students that raise their hand during discussion. At first, the additional “quite time” between the question and response felt a bit uncomfortable. I’m starting to feel a little more relaxed about pausing for an extended amount of time and I am appreciating the additional amount of students who are participating.

The extra time gives all students the opportunity to consider the question and formulate a response. This leads to more thinking and deeper thinking from all students. Students realize that they cannot simply get away with listening to others and recording other students’ ideas in their notebooks or worksheet. The extra time makes it more noticeable to me when students are not taking the time to think about the question that I posed. I have also been asking students to consider the question and jot down their idea in their math notebook. This process lets me see students taking the time to think because I can watch those who are writing versus those who are not. Because of this added step of “jotting down your response,” students feel more exposed when they are not taking this time to think. Since students don’t want to be “caught” not thinking, there has been an increase in participation.

I have, however, noticed a mixed reaction to the extra wait time when I do not include the extra written element. Some students seem frustrated by the extra time because they are fast thinkers and want to keep moving forward to the next task. I am afraid that over time I will lose the interest of these learners because they will get bored waiting and will eventually zone out. I have also noticed that some students are uncomfortable with the wait time. They appear anxious, as if the extra time means the answer should be bigger and better. There are other students who appear to really appreciate the additional time because it gives them the chance to truly think about the question and formulate an appropriate response.

Despite the mixed dispositions I will continue to use wait-time in my practice and play with different delivery approached. There are valuable benefits in using wait time. It sets the stage for higher order thinking, leads to more articulated responses, and more student questions in response to my question. The wait time also helps students connect new information to prior learning. I have recognized more connections to previous material in student responses because they have the time to dig into their brains and resurface old knowledge.

6357 – Five Talk Moves

This week in EDMA 6357 we practiced facilitating an engaging discussion in math class. There have been two classes so far during this quarter and already I can tell that I am going to learn and grow enormously from this course. Since there are only four students in EDMA (myself included) we all get ample time to practice “teaching” in front of the classroom. Since I am taking this course alongside long-term substitute teaching I get the added benefit of practicing what I learn in the course in my actual work setting.

As I mentioned, this week we practiced guiding a math discussion via five essential “talk moves.” The five talk moves are;

1. Revoice – the teacher repeats what she thinks she heard.

2. Repeat – a different student repeats what another student said but using his/her own words. For example I might ask a student “can you retell what Johnny shared with us in a different way?”

3. Reason – ask the students whether or not they agree or disagree with another students point and why.

4. Adding on – ask the class or a student “is there something you would like to add to what Sally shared with us?”

5. Wait time – providing adequate time for students to think about the question being posed and consider a possible response.

I have read about a few of the “talk moves” in other texts but until this class I didn’t have the chance to practice in front of a professor. I found this experience very beneficial because it helped me to recognize places in my instruction where I can instigate participation from other students. For example, during class I asked a question about the number of diagonal in a pentagon and received an answer from one classmate. Since I knew this answer was correct I wrote it up on the white board and moved on. My professor stopped me to point out that at that moment I shut out the rest of the class from participating because I acknowledged that that one student held the correct answer. He suggested that instead of accepting just one answer ask if any other students have a different answer, or if another student would like to add on to what Sue said, etc. I really appreciated this feedback and decided to try in the next day during my teaching.

At present I am teaching 7th grade mathematics. As part of our warm-up I had students practice factoring expressions. I gave them the problem (x) + (4x) and asked them to write the expression in a different but equal way. During discussion I first asked students what form this expression took. I received a unanimous “expanded.” I then asked students to walk me through the factoring process. One student raised his hand and said “first we have to take out the x’s because they are the common piece.” I responded, “Ok, so when I take out the first x what am I left with inside the parenthesis?” One student raised her hand and said “1.” At that point I could have made the mistake of saying “correct” and writing the answer up on the board. Instead I stopped myself and asked, “Does anyone have a different answer?” A few more students raised their hand and one said we would be left with nothing. I asked students to raise their hand if they thought we would be left with nothing…all but two students raised their hand. I then asked if someone could explain to me why we would be left with nothing. One student raised his hand and said because if we have one x in there right now and we take it out then there are no x’s left. I then asked if someone from the “1” camp would like to explain their reasoning. One student volunteered and said, “Well exactly what Jacob said before, if we have one x in there right now and we factor out the x then we have to be left with the number 1 because otherwise we wouldn’t have had an x in there to start with. If we are left with nothing, or zero, then we wouldn’t have an x because zero times x is zero.” I asked if anyone would like to add on to what Max said and show us on the board. One student came up to the board and modeled the factored form and what happens when we redistribute the x back into the expression. I was amazed when I heard a number of students sigh and say “oohhh…I get it…so we can’t have zero because then there wouldn’t be an x!”

I repeated and practiced this discussion in each of the four math classes that I teach. It was so much fun to included more than two or three students in the discussion. I realized that by probing for more information and asking for different answers students are more likely to volunteer their thoughts. I also realized that if I don’t “give away” the correct answer right away with agreeing with certain students I leave the table open for further discussion and explanation. My goal is to continue to practice and refine these five “talk moves.” It takes work and conscious effort but I am excited about the potential these moves can have on my class discussions.

6139 – Teaching Strategies

I can’t believe this is my final week of my internship. The time has gone by so quickly and I am amazed at how comfortable and confident I have become in the classroom. For this final journal entry I want to reflect on the best strategies and resources that I currently use in my classroom. I believe that one of my best strategies is providing students with multiple opportunities to practice their learning. I make an effort to keep instruction time short and break it up frequently so that students stay engaged. I also think it is important for students to immediately practice their learning so I provide practice problems right away. I’ve found that when students have an opportunity to immediately apply their learning they are better able to acknowledge their understandings and misunderstandings. This helps me to immediately address areas of need.

I also use a reading strategy called “think-aloud” with mathematical word problems. I find this method helpful because reading aloud and stopping to narrate how my mind is processing the information helps teach students thinking skills. For example, I might ask myself questions, make inferences, perform an action such as solving, or highlight key words. This process is beneficial because it demonstrates to students what they can or should be doing as they read text in order to help them comprehend better. I really like to use this method when I help students decompose math word problems. For example, recently I asked students to solve the following word problem; “A sprinkler spouts water 5ft ahead as it rotates around counter-clockwise. How much area of yard does the sprinkler water?” Most students wrote 5ft on their papers and stopped. I was surprised by how many students were hesitant to even attempt to answer this question. I decided to help the students out by reading the problem aloud and posing certain questions. For instance, I said, “is the sprinkler rotating around in a circle,” “can I draw a picture of this,” “what does the 5ft represent in my picture of the circle,” “what formula will help me find the area?” These were some of the questions that I posed. I also wrote information on my paper as I read the problem and stopped to draw and/or solve before moving on. I made a point to tell students what I was doing and why.

I find that these two strategies are useful because I’m giving students an opportunity to practice their learning and I’m teaching them mathematical thinking skills. My goal is to help students to successfully read math problems and then identify how the appropriate method for solving. In order to prepare them to do this successfully I need to provide them with the necessary tools and give them time to practice using these tools and ask clarifying questions.

6139 – Motivating Students

For this week’s journal entry I would like to reflect on my second period class. This is an interesting period because I experience the greatest “emotional roller coaster” with these students. There are 30 students in my second period class. All of them are wonderful and each student adds to the personality of the class. Some observations that I have made over the past three months with regards to my second period class are…

  • There is a really big spread of achievement on assessments. With every assessment I have a handful of students who score 100%. Another group of students who regularly score in the 80-90th percentile and make some common mistakes, and then a handful of students who score 50% or below and show no clear evidence of comprehension. Some of these low performing students are on IEP’s or have been exited from special education.
  • There are more students in this period who act indifferent to the information and show little interest in participating. This is challenging for me because it tests my ability to motivate the unmotivated.
  • The overall personality of the class is more variable. It seems that on some days we have an upbeat, positive, and excited feeling in the air, whereas other days we have a more sullen mood within the class. This has been the most interesting observation because it’s very different from my other periods. All of my other classes are fairly consistent in their behavior and exude a generally positive feel. Second period is a little more rocky in the sense that sometimes the class seems engaged and interested and other time they are more reserved, tired, and a few students are even a bit gloomy. Again, this has presented an interesting challenge for me because my job is to maintain a positive, lively learning environment. Often, I can turn the mood of the class if I act a bit more happy and excited and work to engage more students in the conversation.

I must first check myself from engaging in biased thinking about students whom I think cannot change or are “troublesome” students. These students are the ones who need belief from me the most. I’ve recognized how the attitude in the classroom is contagious. For example, when I am upbeat and energetic I carry this attitude over into my teaching and bring out energy from my students. Likewise, student moods can alter the attitude in the classroom. For example, I’ve noticed that on some days I have students in the classroom who are tired and therefore cranky from lack of sleep or not interested in the lesson for the day.

After making these observations I thought about some ways that I can address the needs of second period. I looked to Dr. Allen Mendler’s work for ideas. He suggest five key ways to awaken motivation. Namely,

1)      Show students how achievement benefits life

This is an area that I would like to continue to work on. I’m going to ask other educators how they show, or share with students the benefit of education to success in life.

2)      Create challenges that students can master

“Mendler reasons that students who lack motivation have been so accustomed to thinking that they can’t be successful, that they have to be given small opportunities so they “may be reawakened” to the fact that they can be successful.” I think this is a very important fact to remember. I can help students to feel successful by giving them realizable goals. For instance, by the end of the period I want each of you to complete the first problem. If students finish the first they may go ahead but for students who require more time they only have one problem to focus their energy.

3)      Focus on the teaching and learning process

I can ask myself questions like, is there enough time for the task? Can students be successful at it? Are students sure of the purpose? If I focus on these essential questions I can give better attention to the learning process.

4)      Establish relationships

This is an area that I believe I am fairly solid at. Nevertheless, there is always room for improvement. I would like to incorporate more journal time in math for students to share about their weekend or other personal bits of information. This way, I can read and response to events that go on in their lives so that I can get to know each students as an individual outside of math.

5)      Give rewards for an immediate gain

Rewards can be in the form of written or verbal praise and also point allocation. I would like to incorporate more written feedback and praise on assessments to show students that I truly acknowledge the areas where they are successful or making strides.

Reference List

Mendler, A. (2000). Motivating students who don’t care.

6139 – Week 12

One of my mentor teachers offered me really great “constructive criticism” earlier this week. She started off by telling me that as I become more comfortable in front of the classroom and facilitating discussion I will learn to take student input and “roll with it.” She observed that I sometimes get so caught up in meeting my objective and sticking to the lesson plan for the day that I occasionally brush off really good inquiries or student statements. She admitted that acknowledging student inquiries and branching off into an alternate discussion is a challenging endeavor. It’s a difficult road to take because as teachers we realize our time constraint and the danger in going off path. One of the risks of taking student input and using to fuel discussion is that we might get so wrapped up in some other topic that we won’t meet our learning objective for the day and with thus be off schedule.

My mentor teacher told me that this was one of her greatest challenges at first. When she first started teaching she admitted that she was pretty rigid about sticking to her lesson plan and making sure she met her learning targets. Because of this, she said she often swept past student questions or tried to redirect student to her planned learning target. The shortcoming of this rigidity is that we fail to accept student input and acknowledge different perspectives.

For instance, the other day I posed a warm-up probability question that asked students what they should “add to a bag of marbles to make the probability of drawing blue equal to one half?” The answer that I was looking for was “add six blue marbles.” One student suggested that we take away two yellow and add four blue. Rather than use this as a learning opportunity to talk about key words in the story problem or even to explore alternate ideas, I immediately instructed the student that we were only allowed to “add” marbles and could not take away any. In hindsight I wish I had taking this student’s suggestion and “rolled with it” by asking students to come up with as many possible ways to make “drawing blue equal to one half.” I could have then re-directed students to the key word, “add,” and asked them how we would correctly answer the question.

Using student ideas to aid discussion is a skill that I want to develop further. I think it’s a powerful way to engage students and bring them into the learning process. If I can learn to meet students at their level and then guide them to the learning target I think I will be a much more effective educator. After my mentor teacher gave me this advise I made a greater effort to use student input during my teaching. I think that if I consciously try to improve in this area I will gradually build it into habit. I am excited to practice this skill during my long-term substitute position in the winter.

EDU6160 – Week 7

Chapter 13: If you had to use only one of the three individual student interpretation schemes treated in the chapter (percentiles, grade-equivalent scores, and scale scores), which one would it be? Why did you make that choice?

I would chose percentiles because they are easy to interpret and provide a good understanding of how a student compares relative to the norm group. One trouble with percentiles is that people often read them incorrectly. For example a score of 70% means that the student performed better than 70% of the students in the norm group. It does not mean that the student answered 70% of the questions right. This is often a misunderstanding because percentiles at the school level are not compared to a norm group. Thus, people are comfortable reading percentiles as “70% correct.” I wouldn’t chose grade-equivalent because I think there are too many significant assumptions that are made, such as assuming that the subject is emphasized equally at each grade level. In math class, concepts build on top of each other and some year one topic is emphasized more than other, such as more geometry one year or more algebra another year. Although I see the benefits of using scale scores I wouldn’t personally choose them because I think they are too difficult to interpret and require careful consideration about what scale to use.

Chapter 13: It is sometimes argued that testing companies and state departments of education adopt scale-score reporting methods simply to make it more difficult for everyday citizens to understand how well students perform. Do you think there’s any truth in that criticism?

I think testing companies use scale scores more for the statistical advantage that they provide than for the fact that it’s difficult for people to read. Perhaps the difficulty to interpret is a bonus but I wouldn’t argue that it’s testing companies’ main premise for using scale scores. I would actually argue that testing companies use scale scores to help measures students’ scores between two tests of varied difficulty. Making several tests of equal difficulty and similarity is a very challenging if not impossible task. Scale scores can be utilized to offset the dissimilarity so that scores can be comparable from one test to another. Testing companies have probably chose to use scale scores because then they don’t have to put forth as much effort into creating tests of similar difficulty.

Chapter 14: Can you think of guidelines, other than the two described in the chapter, to be used in evaluating a classroom teacher’s test-preparation practices?

In my opinion, the two guidelines described in the text offer great “umbrella” rules to go by. It’s difficult to think about adding to these guidelines because they are already so broad and all consuming. The only thing that I would like to see added is something about equitable or fair access to necessary accommodations. The goal of a test is to gain an accurate picture of a student’s achievement and ability. However, if some students cannot demonstrate understanding due to certain limitations or lack of access to accommodations, than accurate reading would not be possible. So, I would suggest adding a guideline about providing students with necessary accommodations or modifications in order to create an equitable playing ground to demonstrate knowledge.

Chapter 14: How about test-preparation practices? Can you think of any other sorts of test-preparation guidelines that are meaningfully different from the five described in the chapter? If so, using the chapter’s two evaluative guidelines or any new ones you might prefer, how appropriate are such test-preparation practices?

One test-preparation practice that I would suggest is a more open-ended practice. I have had experience in my own course work where teachers tell me the topics that will be tested but do not provide a review packet. This type of test practice might be called “Concept Focus Preparation” because the goal is to have students review the topics on the list. I think this type of preparation is appropriate for higher-grade levels and advanced students because it offers students a direction but does not limit their study. Often, when students receive a review packet they simply study they content on the packet. Content Focus Preparation would encourage students to expand their study but help keep them focused on a few topics of interest. I think this type of preparation meets the guidelines because students practice with content as it is conceptualized on the test but also with content conceptualized in other ways.

Popham, W.J. (2011). Classroom assessment: What teachers need to know (6th ed.). Boston, MA: Allyn & Bacon.

6139 – Week 11

For this week’s journal entry I would like to reflect on some thoughts that have been surfacing in my mind over the past few days. This past Thursday I gave my students a check-up quiz on probability concepts. The topics being tested included strategies such as tree diagrams and area models to find theoretical probability, identifying the difference between theoretical and experimental probability, and interpreting probabilities and using them to make future predictions. I was pretty confident that my students would perform well because we had just spent two days learning to draw and interpret area models and three days the week before learning to create tree diagrams. I felt I had prepared my students well and believed that most would demonstrate competency.

As I was grading the quizzes I started to recognize some common mistakes. For instance, one question asked, “What are all the possible ways to answer a true/false test with three questions?”  Students were asked to draw a tree diagram and list all possible outcomes. The tree should have looked like this.

Tree Diagram

The possible choices for each question are T or F. The students had to then show these possibilities three times to reflect the three questions. Rather than start with two branches to show the choices T/F, many students started the tree with three branches and labeled them Q1, Q2, and Q3. They then branched off two times from each of these branches to say that each question had two possible choices. This led these students to six possible outcomes rather than eight possible outcomes. I was surprised by how many students made this mistake!

Once I finished grading the quizzes I felt a little discouraged because of how frequently I encountered the same mistake. Yet, I also felt puzzled because there were a good handful of students from each class that earned 100% on the quiz. This led me to believe that I taught the content well because a fair majority was able to demonstrate understanding. But, nevertheless, I still don’t know how to explain the fact that so many students made errors on the tree. I also struggle with how to best correct the misconceptions. Students are taking the unit test this upcoming Thursday and are learning some new content on Monday and Tuesday. This means that I need to find a way to clear up misconceptions while also teaching new content!

This is the first time that I am running into the challenge of limited time. I want to stop pressing forward and simply spend a day or two clearing up misunderstandings and allow students time to practice and refine their skills. However, when I look ahead at the calendar I realize that I am on a very tight schedule. There are many more units that need to be taught between now and the end of the year, and we our projected timeline for each unit shows little room for leeway. How then, do I press forward and make sure students understand their mistakes? And is it right to press forward or should I modify the timeline so that I can spend time re-teaching concepts? Is it dangerous to modify the timeline because will I be tempted to do so more often throughout the rest of the year and end up tight on time at the end of the year?

These are questions that I am sure I will debate for the rest of my career. I hope that as I gain experience I find answers to these questions. For now, I have decided to incorporate a warm-up activity in tomorrows lesson to address the tree diagram misunderstanding. I am going to pose a question to students and ask that they draw a tree in their math journals. I am then going to put up two possible answers on the document camera. I’ll then ask students to choose which answer they think is correct, and explain in their journal why they chose it and why the other one is incorrect. As a class we will then discuss the two choices. Hopefully students will come away from the lesson with a better understanding about how to correctly draw tree diagrams.

 

EDU6160 – Week 6

Chapter 11: Why is it difficult to generate discrimination indices for performance assessments consisting of only one or two fairly elaborate tasks?

It would be difficult to generate discrimination indices for performance assessments consisting of only one or two tasks because each task would represent one half of the total test. Since an item-discrimination index reflects the relationship between students’ responses for the total test and their responses to a particular test item, it would be hard to determine how one item compares to the overall test. Furthermore, if the two tasks require multiple steps or demand that students construct a response, there would be an added difficulty of grading. It seems that discrimination indices are useful on tests that consist of many selected-response items rather than few constructed response items.

Chapter 11: If you found there was a conflict between judgmental and empirical evidence regarding the merits of a particular item, which form of evidence would you be inclined to believe?

For me it would depend on the particular item. If the item was from a performance test consisting of constructed response questions or less objective type questions I would be more inclined to believe the judgmental evidence. Judgmental evidence brings in the “human” element, which I believe is a necessary component when judging test items. The human element helps to consider such things as student experience, background, biases, and how the information tested compared to the level of instruction that was provided. If the item were more objective I would probably first look at the empirical evidence. The empirical evidence would help to point me in the right direction for locating potential problems. I would then compare the empirical with the judgmental and most likely go with judgment.

Chapter 12: What strategies do you believe would be most effective in encouraging more teachers to adopt the formative-assessment process in their own classrooms?

One strategy that I believe would work would be to offer teachers in-service training at the beginning of the school year to provide education about what formative-assessment is and isn’t. Then, give teachers time to plan so that they can think about how to incorporate formative-assessment into their instruction. For example, let teachers plan with others in their content area so that they can create learning-progressions as a team. I also think it would be helpful to give teachers examples and ideas for what formative assessment would look like in their content area. I’m sure that many teachers are aware of the research that supports formative assessment and would like to include it as part of their practice. However, the challenge is often turning an idea into action. Therefore, I think the most effective strategy is to offer teachers training with “hands-on” type practice so that teachers can get familiar with formative-assessment and knowledgeable about how to infuse it into their teaching.

Chapter 12: The chapter was concluded with some speculation about why it is that formative assessment is not used more widely. If you had to choose the single most important impediment that prevents more teachers from employing formative assessment, what would this one impediment be? Do you think it is possible to remove this impediment?

I would say the single most important impediment that prevents more teachers from employing formative assessment is “teachers’ tendencies to resist altering their current conduct.” The reason I think this is because teachers have established their habits and have figured out methods that are efficient and effective. Limitations on time hinder a teachers’ ability to make major changes to their practice. During the school year teachers are too busy with day-to-day activities, forming relationships with students, communicating with parents, planning lessons for the next day, grading papers, etc. There simply isn’t the time to devote to adding something brand new to the mix. Thus, teachers resort to old habits that they have found effective.

Removing this impediment would require major adjustments. One strategy that could work is to give teachers a block of paid training and planning time at the beginning of the school year. During this time teachers would be educated on formative assessment and coached on how to create learning progressions. I think follow-up trainings should occur throughout the year to help answer questions and refine methods. Perhaps once every two or three months teachers could have an in-service training day to spend on planning and asking questions. In order to make big changes and bring in formative assessment there needs to be continual training and revisiting. Otherwise, teachers will simply forget about it and resort to what they know.

Popham, W.J. (2011). Classroom assessment: What teachers need to know (6th ed.). Boston, MA: Allyn & Bacon.

Previous Older Entries

Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free